Navigation Links
Study explores effects of review setting on scientific peer review
Date:8/7/2013

RESTON, VIRGINIA Research findings published today in PLOS ONE report that the setting in which a scientific peer review panel evaluates grant applications does not necessarily impact the outcome of the review process. However, the research found that the average amount of discussion panelists engage in during the review is reduced. The investigation examined more than 1,600 grant application reviews coordinated by the American Institute of Biological Sciences Scientific Peer Advisory and Review Services (AIBS SPARS) on behalf of a federal agency over a four-year period.

The researchers compared two years when grant applications were reviewed using an in-person peer review panel to two years when panels were conducted via teleconference or videoconference.

Funding organizations routinely bring experts together to review research grant applications. A process known as scientific peer review, the goal of these panels is to identify the best research applications.

"There are no studies exploring whether the review setting significantly alters the quality of the peer review process," stated Dr. Stephen Gallo, the lead author of this study and Technical Operations Manager for AIBS SPARS.

"Our goal is always a reliable and high-quality peer-review process. It is important that we understand the strengths and weaknesses of different peer review methods," said Scott Glisson, Director of AIBS SPARS and an author of this study.

The findings appear in "Teleconference Versus Face-To-Face Scientific Peer Review of Grant Applications: Effects on Review Outcomes" published in PLOS ONE.

"Little difference was found in most of the review metrics between face-to-face and teleconference settings," said Gallo. Application scoring was only modestly affected and reviewers used the full scoring range regardless of review setting. The reviewer ratings were highly reliable in both settings.

O
'/>"/>

Contact: Robert Gropp
rgropp@aibs.org
202-628-1500 x250
American Institute of Biological Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Women in urban areas show high rates of postpartum depression, study finds
2. Study questions natures ability to self-correct climate change
3. UCSB study finds climate change is causing modifications to marine life behavior
4. Study reveals potential role of love hormone oxytocin in brain function
5. Mount Sinai researchers develop first successful laboratory model for studying hepatitis C
6. Study finds physicians need to better recognize use of herbal supplements while breastfeeding
7. Study highlights possible new approach to prostate cancer treatment
8. Breath analysis reliably indicates presence, level of infection in mice, UCI study finds
9. Southerners are less trusting, but trust is a factor in environmental cooperation, study shows
10. Study investigates extraordinary trout with tolerance to heavily polluted water
11. Extinct ancient ape did not walk like a human, study shows
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/2/2014)... researchers at the University of Warwick in the UK ... in the Journal Early Human Development , has ... hospital after birth and the use of mechanical ventilation ... children. , Mathematic abilities are crucial for lifelong academic ... preterm children. Earlier studies of children who are born ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... is considered the most ideal source of nutrition ... critical role in the evolution and civilizations of ... contains a large number of bacterial species, including ... as no surprise to scientists and physicians. , ... to be the result of co-evolutionary and co-adaptive ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... 2, 2014) In the battle between our immune ... ally in bacteria-killing viruses known as phages. In a ... Partners In Health, Haiti,s National Public Health Laboratory, and ... give up their virulence in order to survive. Importantly, ... found that cholera,s mutational escape from phage predation occurs ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Mechanical ventilation a key indicator for pre-term children's math problems 2Are human breast milk microbiome 'neutral'? 2Are human breast milk microbiome 'neutral'? 3War between bacteria and phages benefits humans 2War between bacteria and phages benefits humans 3
... Society has announced the winners of its second ... Society,s 57th Annual Meeting at the Pennsylvania Convention ... Society,s Committee for Professional Opportunities for Women (CPOW), ... number of women biophysicists and encourage their participation ...
... male jaguar and an adult male ocelot have been photographed ... monitoring cameras. The images were collected as part of the ... Arizona. Both animals appear to be in good health. ... from wildlife cameras set up as part of the research ...
... LA JOLLA, CA January 8, 2013 - Chemists at The ... one of the most fundamental tasks in molecular biology. Their new ... that these cells may be easily located and/or selected out from ... in a recent issue of the chemistry journal Angewandte Chemie ...
Cached Biology News:Biophysical Society announces winners of 2013 CPOW travel awards 2Wildlife monitoring cameras click jaguar and ocelot photos 2Wildlife monitoring cameras click jaguar and ocelot photos 3Chemists devise inexpensive, benchtop method for marking and selecting cells 2Chemists devise inexpensive, benchtop method for marking and selecting cells 3
(Date:8/31/2014)... Texas (PRWEB) August 31, 2014 ... the current state of the Epoxy Hardener ... a basic overview of the industry, including definitions, ... and Chinese domestic market analysis are provided with ... landscape of the market. A comparison between the ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... August 29, 2014 The global ... billion in 2019. It is expected to grow ... 2019, and was valued at $1.8 billion in ... Transparency Market Research. , For more information regarding ... . , The research report, titled “Companion Diagnostics ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... Hills, NY (PRWEB) August 29, 2014 ... Burnt Hills Veterinary Hospital are seeking candidates to participate ... dogs with osteoarthritis. The ultimate goal of this ... donor stem cells into one or two arthritically affected ... treated joints. , Candidates for the current investigational ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... San Antonio, TX (PRWEB) August 29, 2014 ... 9001:2008 and ISO 13485:2003 certified, GAMP® 5 compliant ... been awarded an international Phase II clinical trial ... non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. , Throughout this trial, Intrinsic Imaging ... but not limited to, protocol and charter development, ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Epoxy Hardener Industry Development Trends in Global & China Regions Now Available at ReportsnReports.com 2Epoxy Hardener Industry Development Trends in Global & China Regions Now Available at ReportsnReports.com 3Companion Diagnostics Market to Hit $5.6 Billion in 2019: Transparency Market Research 2Companion Diagnostics Market to Hit $5.6 Billion in 2019: Transparency Market Research 3Burnt Hills Veterinary Hospital Seeks Candidates for an Investigational Study of Stem Cells for Dogs with Arthritis 2Intrinsic Imaging Awarded Phase II Clinical Trial to Assess New Treatment for Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma 2
... HALIFAX, May 23 /PRNewswire/ - ImmunoVaccine Technologies Inc. ... for being,recognized as one of Pennsylvania,s Best 50 ... of Immunotope Inc., received the honors,from Pennsylvania Governor ... in the biotech industry. Her clinical work in,antigen ...
... EXTON, Pa., May 23 BioTrends Research ... Nephrology," providing insight,into the referral patterns and ... from the perspective of Nephrologists,Cardiologists, Endocrinologists, and ... offers a comprehensive view, based on,qualitative interviews ...
... and PHILADELPHIA, Pennsylvania, May 23, Shire Limited ("Shire") (LSE: ... an,application has been made to the UK Listing Authority ... of 5 pence each in the,capital of Shire to ... on the,London Stock Exchange. Dealings will commence today at ...
Cached Biology Technology:ImmunoVaccine Technologies Congratulates Dr. Ramila Philip as One of PA's Best 50 Women in Business 2Nephrologists and Non-Nephrologists Alike Report Increased Attention on Chronic Kidney Disease 2Application for Listing of Shire Limited Ordinary Shares 2Application for Listing of Shire Limited Ordinary Shares 3