Navigation Links
Study explores effects of review setting on scientific peer review
Date:8/7/2013

RESTON, VIRGINIA Research findings published today in PLOS ONE report that the setting in which a scientific peer review panel evaluates grant applications does not necessarily impact the outcome of the review process. However, the research found that the average amount of discussion panelists engage in during the review is reduced. The investigation examined more than 1,600 grant application reviews coordinated by the American Institute of Biological Sciences Scientific Peer Advisory and Review Services (AIBS SPARS) on behalf of a federal agency over a four-year period.

The researchers compared two years when grant applications were reviewed using an in-person peer review panel to two years when panels were conducted via teleconference or videoconference.

Funding organizations routinely bring experts together to review research grant applications. A process known as scientific peer review, the goal of these panels is to identify the best research applications.

"There are no studies exploring whether the review setting significantly alters the quality of the peer review process," stated Dr. Stephen Gallo, the lead author of this study and Technical Operations Manager for AIBS SPARS.

"Our goal is always a reliable and high-quality peer-review process. It is important that we understand the strengths and weaknesses of different peer review methods," said Scott Glisson, Director of AIBS SPARS and an author of this study.

The findings appear in "Teleconference Versus Face-To-Face Scientific Peer Review of Grant Applications: Effects on Review Outcomes" published in PLOS ONE.

"Little difference was found in most of the review metrics between face-to-face and teleconference settings," said Gallo. Application scoring was only modestly affected and reviewers used the full scoring range regardless of review setting. The reviewer ratings were highly reliable in both settings.

O
'/>"/>

Contact: Robert Gropp
rgropp@aibs.org
202-628-1500 x250
American Institute of Biological Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Women in urban areas show high rates of postpartum depression, study finds
2. Study questions natures ability to self-correct climate change
3. UCSB study finds climate change is causing modifications to marine life behavior
4. Study reveals potential role of love hormone oxytocin in brain function
5. Mount Sinai researchers develop first successful laboratory model for studying hepatitis C
6. Study finds physicians need to better recognize use of herbal supplements while breastfeeding
7. Study highlights possible new approach to prostate cancer treatment
8. Breath analysis reliably indicates presence, level of infection in mice, UCI study finds
9. Southerners are less trusting, but trust is a factor in environmental cooperation, study shows
10. Study investigates extraordinary trout with tolerance to heavily polluted water
11. Extinct ancient ape did not walk like a human, study shows
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/15/2014)... need for vitamin E and how much is enough, ... of this essential micronutrient are especially critical for the ... may become pregnant. , A lifelong proper intake of ... complicated by the fact that this nutrient is one ... It has been estimated that only a tiny fraction ...
(Date:9/12/2014)... , September 12, 2014 ... http://www.researchandmarkets.com/research/trs4c7/global ) has announced the addition of ... 2014" report to their offering. ,     ... Report 2014 is a professional and in-depth ... global fingerprint lock industry. , ,The report ...
(Date:9/12/2014)... of New York biologist Mike Hickerson, a team of international ... so many species of birds ended up in the Neotropics, ... the southernmost tip of South America. It is home to ... has beenhow did this extraordinary bird diversity originate?" said Dr. ... published in the journal Nature this week and ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Vitamin E intake critical during 'the first 1,000 days' 2Vitamin E intake critical during 'the first 1,000 days' 3Global Fingerprint Lock Industry Report 2014 2
... of Biologists is pleased to announce BIOLOGY OPEN (BiO), ... research across all aspects of the biological sciences including ... journal aims to provide rapid publication for peer reviewed, ... fields. BIOLOGY OPEN will address some big issues ...
... a big effect on their life. Some people are ... which can be detrimental to their health and wellbeing. ... , A new study led by Dr Kathryn ... York has added important experimental evidence showing that animal ...
... fish, one from a Caribbean island and one from the Yucatan ... known in any organism, according to a new UC Davis study. ... Venezuela -- and they are all pretty much the same, said ... with Peter Wainwright, a professor of evolution and ecology at UC ...
Cached Biology News:Announcing BIOLOGY OPEN from the Company of Biologists 2Animals have personalities, too 2'Explosive' evolution in pupfish 2
(Date:9/15/2014)... interdisciplinary team of researchers led by Northeastern University ... precise inter-nanotube junctions and a variety of nanocarbon ... facile and easily scalable, which will allow the ... networks for use in applications ranging from electronic ... from cars to sports equipment. , Their findings ...
(Date:9/15/2014)... , Sept. 15, 2014  iVinci Health LLC, the ... Patient Revenue Management system, branded as VisitPay®, has successfully ... announced the launch of a new extension to VisitPay® ... an easy and convenient way for patients to manage ... owed by them and their families. The ...
(Date:9/15/2014)... CA (PRWEB) September 15, 2014 ... term implantable silicones for the medical device and ... silicone gel for the implantable medical device market. ... unique crosslink technology delivering a silicone gel with ... The Dual Matrix technology consists of two crosslinked ...
(Date:9/15/2014)... septiembre de 2014 La segunda anual International ... 12 al 18 de octubre. Como iniciativa conjunta de la ... compañías miembro s, la IPAW se ha diseñado para: ... a la colección de fuentes de plasma , Reconocimiento ... y mejorar las vidas , Aumento del conocimiento sobre ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Northeastern University Researchers Develop Novel Method for Working with Nanotubes 2iVinci Health Raises $5M to Fuel National Expansion, Announces Launch of Personal Finance Portal for Healthcare 2iVinci Health Raises $5M to Fuel National Expansion, Announces Launch of Personal Finance Portal for Healthcare 3Applied Silicone Launches Silicone Gel System with Dual Matrix Technology 2La International Plasma Awareness Week será una celebración para los donantes 2La International Plasma Awareness Week será una celebración para los donantes 3
... 2008 at 9:00 a.m. Eastern ... ... ALSE ) today reports operational and,financial results for the quarter ended ... http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20080813/NEW056LOGO ), "We are encouraged by the progress we ...
... Named Contract Manufacturer of Choice, Based on Its ... Based on its recent,analysis of the pharmaceutical ... BioPharma Solutions (BPS) with the 2008 North,American Frost ... Award at,the 2008 Excellence in Healthcare Innovation Awards ...
... Novavax uses strategies to create vaccines for avian flu ... genetically-engineered virus-like particles (VLPs), ROCKVILLE, Md., ... today that its strategy for treating avian flu,through genetically-engineered ... at Cleveland Clinic 6th Annual Medical Innovation,Summit., Novavax, ...
Cached Biology Technology:Alseres Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2008 Operational and Financial Results 2Alseres Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2008 Operational and Financial Results 3Alseres Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2008 Operational and Financial Results 4Alseres Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2008 Operational and Financial Results 5Frost & Sullivan Awards Baxter's BioPharma Solutions Business the 2008 North American Customer Service Leadership of the Year Award 2Frost & Sullivan Awards Baxter's BioPharma Solutions Business the 2008 North American Customer Service Leadership of the Year Award 3Cleveland Clinic Recognizes New Strategies for Creating Vaccines for Avian Flu as a Top Ten Medical Innovation for 2009 2Cleveland Clinic Recognizes New Strategies for Creating Vaccines for Avian Flu as a Top Ten Medical Innovation for 2009 3Cleveland Clinic Recognizes New Strategies for Creating Vaccines for Avian Flu as a Top Ten Medical Innovation for 2009 4
... Single Cell Whole Genome Amplification Kit ... random fragmentation of genomic DNA and ... to PCR-amplifiable library molecules flanked by ... by PCR amplification of the library ...
Mouse monoclonal antibody to QARS - glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase...
Rabbit Anti-Mouse Ym1 Polyclonal Antibody,...
From formula-fed bovine calves Sterile, Cell culture tested...
Biology Products: