Navigation Links
Study compares cost-effectiveness of weight-loss programs and drugs
Date:7/22/2014

/p>

In terms of cost, Weight Watchers was shown to be the least expensive intervention, consisting of an average annual cost of $377. The expected annual cost for Vtrim users was $682. Because of the relatively high cost of Jenny Craig food, it was the most expensive intervention, with an annual cost of more than $2,500.

Expected annual costs for the diet pills was $1,743 for Lorcaserin; $1,518 for Orlistat; and $1,336 for Qsymia.

Average weight loss at one year ranged from 2.4 kg (about 5 pounds) for Weight Watchers to 7.4 kg (16 pounds) for Jenny Craig. Those on Orlistat lost 2.8 kg (a little more than 6 pounds) whereas those on Vtrim and Lorcaserin both lost an average of 3.2 kg (about 7 pounds). Weight loss for those on Qsymia averaged 6.7kg (a little less than 15 pounds).

Based on the cost and weight-loss data, the average cost per kilogram lost ranged from $155 per kg for Weight Watchers to $338 or more for Jenny Craig. Qsymia came in at $232 per kg.

When the analysis was extended from cost per kilogram lost to cost per quality adjusted life year saved (QALY), the researchers found that Weight Watchers and Qsymia showed the best value for money. QALYs are often used to benchmark the value of a particular health innovation, with high value interventions typically improving QALYs at a rate of $50,000 or better.

"Health policy makers do not understand value in terms of cost per kilogram lost, but if you tell them that an intervention improves QALYs at better than $50K per QALY saved, they recognize that as good value for money," Finkelstein said.

For the remaining interventions, the additional weight loss came at a price higher than what third-party payers would be likely to cover without significant cost-sharing by participants.

"Although containing rising rates of obesity is a public health imperative, employers and third-party payers remain hesitant to sink big money into commercial weight
'/>"/>

Contact: Sarah Avery
sarah.avery@duke.edu
919-660-1306
Duke University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. Study by UC Santa Barbara researchers suggests that bacteria communicate by touch
2. Law that regulates shark fishery is too liberal: UBC study
3. New study will help protect vulnerable birds from impacts of climate change
4. Study jointly led by UCSB researcher supports theory of extraterrestrial impact
5. BYU study: Using a gun in bear encounters doesnt make you safer
6. 15-year study: When it comes to creating wetlands, Mother Nature is in charge
7. Pycnogenol (French maritime pine bark extract) shown to improve menopause symptoms in new study
8. Crystal structure of archael chromatin clarified in new study
9. EU-funded study underlines importance of Congo Basin for global climate and biodiversity
10. University of Houston study shows BP oil spill hurt marshes, but recovery possible
11. Study demonstrates cells can acquire new functions through transcriptional regulatory network
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/27/2015)... , Apr. 27, 2015 Profile Solutions, ... control and security systems is pleased to announce that ... as a consultant and member of its scientific advisory ... widely known as a thought leader in technology-enhanced learning ... Technology Group, and has published studies and books focused ...
(Date:4/20/2015)... , April 20, 2015 ...   Glenbeigh Records Management (GRM), Ireland,s ... with Dubai Islamic Bank. Having built up an impressive track ... now a leading player within the records management sector in ... expects to double is GCC staffbase and employ a further ...
(Date:4/14/2015)... , April 14, 2015 NXT-ID, Inc. ... biometric authentication company focused on the growing mobile commerce ... nominated for the 2015 New York Design Awards under ... Design100, New York City Design Awards are part of ... on over 2,500 ratings from the marketplace, industry and ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Profile Solutions Names Medicinal Cannabis, Agriculture and Technology Expert Dr. Gerry Bedore to its Scientific Advisory Board 2Profile Solutions Names Medicinal Cannabis, Agriculture and Technology Expert Dr. Gerry Bedore to its Scientific Advisory Board 3Profile Solutions Names Medicinal Cannabis, Agriculture and Technology Expert Dr. Gerry Bedore to its Scientific Advisory Board 4Glenbeigh Records Management Wins Contract With Dubai Islamic Bank 2Glenbeigh Records Management Wins Contract With Dubai Islamic Bank 3NXT-ID's Wocket Smart Wallet Nominated for 2015 New York Design Awards in 'Product Design- Technology' 2NXT-ID's Wocket Smart Wallet Nominated for 2015 New York Design Awards in 'Product Design- Technology' 3
... Va., Nov. 18 Stanley, Inc.,(NYSE: SXE ... to the U.S. federal government, today announced that it ... Corporation (NYSE: SAI ) awarded,a four-year, cost-plus-fixed-fee ... three option years are exercised. With this award, the ...
... NY, November 18, 2008 -- Researchers at the University of ... have been used to block and reverse type 1 diabetes ... of the National Academy of Sciences , was led by ... and an expert in the field of autoimmunity. "The ...
... Materials engineers have created a new type of membrane ... be used for environmental cleanup, water purification and industrial ... conventional filters for separating oil from water and works ... usually mutually exclusive. Researchers attached the material to a ...
Cached Biology News:Stanley to Continue Biometrics In-Service Engineering Support for U.S. Army 2Stanley to Continue Biometrics In-Service Engineering Support for U.S. Army 3New filtering technology has environmental, industrial applications 2New filtering technology has environmental, industrial applications 3
(Date:5/21/2015)... /PRNewswire/ - RepliCel Life Sciences Inc. (TSX.V: RP) ... focused on the development of autologous cell therapies, ... International Society for Cellular Therapy (ISCT) on RepliCel,s ... in a Phase 1/2 clinical trial.  The presentation, ... 5:30 PM to 7:00 PM local time, will ...
(Date:5/20/2015)... Calif. , May 20, 2015 ... today presented preliminary data demonstrating the ability of ... pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) from other interstitial lung diseases ... suggest the classifier,s potential to help thousands of ... resolve ambiguity in IPF diagnosis – a frequent ...
(Date:5/20/2015)... and Markets ( http://www.researchandmarkets.com/research/qfxkcq/global_cell ) has announced ... Outlook 2020 " report to their offering. ... medicine is expected to have huge marketing potential. Presently, ... the growth of deregulated organs. Several therapeutic molecules are ... form new tissue or sometimes organ transplant is required. ...
(Date:5/20/2015)... , May 20, 2015  Health eCareers, ... short-staffed healthcare organizations with job seekers looking for ... , a new mobile and online tool dedicated ... healthcare industry. SHIFT enables employers to ... tenens, travel nursing, per diem and other temporary ...
Breaking Biology Technology:RepliCel to Present Unique Autologous Cell Treatment for Achilles Tendinosis at International Society for Cellular Therapy Conference 2RepliCel to Present Unique Autologous Cell Treatment for Achilles Tendinosis at International Society for Cellular Therapy Conference 3Veracyte Presents Preliminary Data Demonstrating Ability of Molecular Classifier to Improve Non-Surgical IPF Diagnosis Using Bronchoscopy Samples 2Veracyte Presents Preliminary Data Demonstrating Ability of Molecular Classifier to Improve Non-Surgical IPF Diagnosis Using Bronchoscopy Samples 3Veracyte Presents Preliminary Data Demonstrating Ability of Molecular Classifier to Improve Non-Surgical IPF Diagnosis Using Bronchoscopy Samples 4Veracyte Presents Preliminary Data Demonstrating Ability of Molecular Classifier to Improve Non-Surgical IPF Diagnosis Using Bronchoscopy Samples 5Global Cell Therapy Market Outlook 2015-2020 - 262 Cell Therapies & 13 Marketed Cell Therapies 2Global Cell Therapy Market Outlook 2015-2020 - 262 Cell Therapies & 13 Marketed Cell Therapies 3Health eCareers Launches SHIFT Mobile and Online Tool to Match Healthcare Employers with Temporary Job Seekers 2Health eCareers Launches SHIFT Mobile and Online Tool to Match Healthcare Employers with Temporary Job Seekers 3
... New research at Rice University shows that tiny worlds may ... Pulickel Ajayan has packed an entire lithium ion energy storage ... the American Chemical Society journal Nano Letters . The ... can possibly get, and could be valuable as a rechargeable ...
... July 28, 2011 BioMed Realty Trust, Inc. ... signing of a new lease with BIND Biosciences, ... Cambridge, Massachusetts.  BIND Biosciences, a biopharmaceutical company developing ... approximately 32,800 square feet of laboratory and office ...
... 2011 TriLink BioTechnologies, Inc. (TriLink) and Lucigen Corporation ... a licensing agreement for the use of TriLink,s CleanAmp™ ... TriLink,s CleanAmp™ dNTPs are an innovative approach ... dNTPs in a PCR assay with CleanAmp™ dNTPs, a ...
Cached Biology Technology:Rice scientists build battery in a nanowire 2Rice scientists build battery in a nanowire 3BioMed Realty Trust and BIND Biosciences Sign New Lease at Vassar Street Property 2BioMed Realty Trust and BIND Biosciences Sign New Lease at Vassar Street Property 3BioMed Realty Trust and BIND Biosciences Sign New Lease at Vassar Street Property 4TriLink BioTechnologies, Inc. Announces License Agreement with Lucigen Corporation 2