Navigation Links
Has modern science become dysfunctional?
Date:3/27/2012

The recent explosion in the number of retractions in scientific journals is just the tip of the iceberg and a symptom of a greater dysfunction that has been evolving the world of biomedical research say the editors-in-chief of two prominent journals in a presentation before a committee of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) today.

"Incentives have evolved over the decades to encourage some behaviors that are detrimental to good science," says Ferric Fang, editor-in-chief of the journal Infection and Immunity, a publication of the American Society for Microbiology (ASM), who is speaking today at the meeting of the Committee of Science, Technology, and Law of the NAS along with Arturo Casadevall, editor-in -chief of mBio, the ASM's online, open-access journal.

In the past decade the number of retraction notices for scientific journals has increased more than 10-fold while the number of journals articles published has only increased by 44%. While retractions still represent a very small percentage of the total, the increase is still disturbing because it undermines society's confidence in scientific results and on public policy decisions that are based on those results, says Casadevall. Some of the retractions are due to simple error but many are a result of misconduct including falsification of data and plagiarism.

More concerning, say the editors, is that this trend may be a symptom of a growing dysfunction in the biomedical sciences, one that needs to be addressed soon. At the heart of the problem is an economic incentive system fueling a hypercompetitive environment that is fostering poor scientific practices, including frank misconduct.

The root of the problem is a lack of sufficient resources to sustain the current enterprise. Too many researchers are competing for too little funding, creating a survival-of-the-fittest, winner-take-all environment where researchers increasingly feel pressure to publ
'/>"/>

Contact: Jim Sliwa
jsliwa@asmusa.org
202-942-9297
American Society for Microbiology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Ancient whale species sheds new light on its modern relatives
2. Modern Mobility Aids, Inc. Announces a Revised Agreement for the Acquisition of Lumigene
3. European Neandertals were on the verge of extinction even before the arrival of modern humans
4. Modern genetics answers age-old question on Garrods fourth inborn error of metabolism
5. Invasion of genomic parasites triggered modern mammalian pregnancy
6. Evolutions past is modern humans present
7. Researchers discover oldest evidence of nails in modern primates
8. Modern fish communities live fast and die young
9. Modern EU agriculture jeopardizes biodiversity in new member states
10. Mummies tell history of a modern plague
11. Low-cost molecular medicine should be included in modern eye physicians tool kit
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/23/2014)... in their mid-thirties and forties, face a devastating ... two decades. "Mutant" protein clusters, long blamed for ... the primary focus of therapies in development by ... Prof. Gerardo Lederkremer and Dr. Julia Leitman of ... Immunology, in collaboration with Prof. Ulrich Hartl of ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... Toronto Scarborough research shows that male black widow spiders ... a rare example of mate preference by male spiders. ... Emily MacLeod and Maydianne Andrade, a professor in UTSC,s ... studies and the wild that males overwhelmingly chose to ... black widows can tell whether a potential mate is ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... source of a unique rhythmic sound, recorded for decades ... the Antarctic minke whale ( Balaenoptera bonaerensis ). First ... who thought it sounded like a duck, the bio-duck ... Southern Ocean, but its source has remained a mystery, ... of researchers deployed acoustic tags on two Antarctic minke ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):On the defensive 2On the defensive 3Picky male black widow spiders prefer well-fed virgins 2Scientists identify source of mysterious sound in the Southern Ocean 2Scientists identify source of mysterious sound in the Southern Ocean 3
... have uncovered a dramatic new twist in the battle against ... itself immune to a key component of the only effective ... team of TB researchers at Leicester announced a new advance ... They isolated the molecular weapons of the bacterium and are ...
... spring arrives across the country, tourists returning to beaches will ... algae that make water unfit for swimming and pose risks ... realize is that the small streams running through their neighborhoods ... feeds the algae blooms. A new study published in ...
... RIDGE, Tenn., March 12, 2008 -- Noted green energy ... this years Global Venture Challenge, a business competition and ... Ridge National Laboratory. The focus of this years ... bioenergy, energy efficiency and power generation sectors. Sridhar, ...
Cached Biology News:Scientists discover how TB 'develops invincibility' against only available treatment 2From the backyard to the ocean: New study shows streams act as key nitrogen filters 2
(Date:1/15/2014)... "The interface is the device," Nobel laureate Herbert ... to be found at the junctures where layers ... of nanotechnology, the interfaces between layers of metal ... such high-tech favorites as spintronics, high-temperature superconductors, ferroelectrics ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... 15, 2014 Cynvenio, a cancer diagnostics ... the genomic analysis of tumor cells in the bloodstream, ... web-based cancer decision support application powered by CollabRx, Inc. ... ClearID™ genomic test, Therapy Finder will provide breast cancer ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... More than 5 million Americans are currently ... seniors will die with Alzheimer’s or another dementia, according ... shocked many Americans into looking for ways to improve ... age-related cognitive disorders. Jonathan Weisman, president of Biohack Pure, ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... Freeslate, Inc ., the leading ... Lupin Limited, one of India’s top five pharmaceutical companies, ... System for high throughput solid form screening. ... a wide range of quality, affordable generic and branded ...
Breaking Biology Technology:A deeper look at interfaces 2Cynvenio Offers New Breast Cancer Therapy Finder Application for its ClearID Breast Cancer Genomic Test 2Cynvenio Offers New Breast Cancer Therapy Finder Application for its ClearID Breast Cancer Genomic Test 3Biohack Pure Offers 5 Tips for Increasing Memory in 2014 2Lupin Selects Freeslate’s CM Protégé PharmD System to Accelerate Polymorph Screening for Drug Development 2Lupin Selects Freeslate’s CM Protégé PharmD System to Accelerate Polymorph Screening for Drug Development 3
... hair-like blood vessels in the back of our eyes, researchers ... those that bring blood to the heart respond to air ... otherwise healthy people exposed to high levels of air pollution ... of heart disease. Previous studies linked pollution to heart ...
... An international team of researchers has succeeded in creating ... for the first time, allowing them to examine the ... the University of Leeds, the US Department of Energy,s ... Facilities Council,s Rutherford Appleton Laboratory say the breakthrough will ...
... Mass. -- Researchers at Tufts University School of Engineering have ... and two variations, using E. coli as the ... 24, 2010, issue of Chemistry and Biology, offers ... new drugs that will combat the growing incidence of antibiotic ...
Cached Biology Technology:Photos of tiny blood vessels in the eye link air pollution to heart disease 2Scientists create highly ordered artificial spin ice using nanotechnology 2Scientists create highly ordered artificial spin ice using nanotechnology 3Erythromycin A produced in E. coli for first time 2
Procollagen type I C-terminal propeptide (human, PICP)...
... in Early Drug Development with Imaging Mass ... drug compound localization data in early drug ... mass spectrometry service maps unlabeled ... so you can localize drugs and metabolites ...
... LC Sciences provides a unique new ... DNA synthesis serving diverse needs in genomics, ... applications. OligoMix is a MIXTURE of a ... sequences delivered in a single microtube. OligoMix ...
... is an automated, high-resolution protein analysis ... ProteomeLab family of products, the PA ... automated protein characterization solutions including molecular ... carbohydrate profiling and mechanisms to study ...
Biology Products: