Navigation Links
Has modern science become dysfunctional?
Date:3/27/2012

The recent explosion in the number of retractions in scientific journals is just the tip of the iceberg and a symptom of a greater dysfunction that has been evolving the world of biomedical research say the editors-in-chief of two prominent journals in a presentation before a committee of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) today.

"Incentives have evolved over the decades to encourage some behaviors that are detrimental to good science," says Ferric Fang, editor-in-chief of the journal Infection and Immunity, a publication of the American Society for Microbiology (ASM), who is speaking today at the meeting of the Committee of Science, Technology, and Law of the NAS along with Arturo Casadevall, editor-in -chief of mBio, the ASM's online, open-access journal.

In the past decade the number of retraction notices for scientific journals has increased more than 10-fold while the number of journals articles published has only increased by 44%. While retractions still represent a very small percentage of the total, the increase is still disturbing because it undermines society's confidence in scientific results and on public policy decisions that are based on those results, says Casadevall. Some of the retractions are due to simple error but many are a result of misconduct including falsification of data and plagiarism.

More concerning, say the editors, is that this trend may be a symptom of a growing dysfunction in the biomedical sciences, one that needs to be addressed soon. At the heart of the problem is an economic incentive system fueling a hypercompetitive environment that is fostering poor scientific practices, including frank misconduct.

The root of the problem is a lack of sufficient resources to sustain the current enterprise. Too many researchers are competing for too little funding, creating a survival-of-the-fittest, winner-take-all environment where researchers increasingly feel pressure to publ
'/>"/>

Contact: Jim Sliwa
jsliwa@asmusa.org
202-942-9297
American Society for Microbiology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Ancient whale species sheds new light on its modern relatives
2. Modern Mobility Aids, Inc. Announces a Revised Agreement for the Acquisition of Lumigene
3. European Neandertals were on the verge of extinction even before the arrival of modern humans
4. Modern genetics answers age-old question on Garrods fourth inborn error of metabolism
5. Invasion of genomic parasites triggered modern mammalian pregnancy
6. Evolutions past is modern humans present
7. Researchers discover oldest evidence of nails in modern primates
8. Modern fish communities live fast and die young
9. Modern EU agriculture jeopardizes biodiversity in new member states
10. Mummies tell history of a modern plague
11. Low-cost molecular medicine should be included in modern eye physicians tool kit
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:10/16/2014)... Institute of Marine Science have received a 3-year, ... identify the streams and wetlands most vulnerable to ... local governments and citizens conserve these important ecosystems. ... of tidal-marsh observations first gathered by VIMS scientists ... can today,s researchers accurately map the slow but ...
(Date:10/16/2014)... respiratory tract infections and worldwide claims the lives ... and Ghent University have succeeded in developing a ... infection. , Xavier Saelens (VIB/UGent): "We discovered ... for the development of a novel approach to ... in numerous small children and elderly people." , ...
(Date:10/15/2014)... assess the pandemic risk from strains of influenza virus ... allow ourselves to become complacent that the most substantial ... scientists. , Influenza pandemics arise when a new virus ... widespread immunity – spreads in the human population. There ... years, the worst of which – the 1918 Spanish ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):EPA grant will help localities conserve headwater wetlands 2EPA grant will help localities conserve headwater wetlands 3New perspectives for development of an RSV vaccine 2Scientists 'must not become complacent' when assessing pandemic threat from flu viruses 2
... A large collaborative study has added to the ... a person will be. The research, published by Cell ... of Human Genetics , identifies uncommon and previously unknown ... the genetic architecture of other complex traits. Although ...
... Most agricultural crops require large quantities of ... for growers is finding ways to balance the ... potentially harmful nitrates that can leach into ground ... "low-input" approaches is challenging researchers to identify genotypes ...
... traditionally relied heavily on hand thinning, a necessary but ... costs and a limited workforce, peach and other stone ... string thinners to minimize the need for hand thinning. ... when it was evaluated in four U.S. growing regions; ...
Cached Biology News:Large-scale analysis identifies new genetic alterations associated with height 2Improving nitrogen use efficiency lessens environmental impact 2Hybrid string blossom thinner tested in peach orchards 2
(Date:10/20/2014)... , Oct. 20, 2014 PureTech , ... tackling big healthcare problems, announced today the closing ... with participation from Invesco Perpetual, a $120 Billion ... to drive PureTech,s existing pipeline forward and to ... has the scientific creativity to really go for ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... 20, 2014 Local veterinary surgeon, Dr. ... investigational study of donor stem cells for dogs with ... therapy and has performed clinical stem cell therapy for ... to determine if a single injection of donor stem ... help reduce pain and inflammation in the treated joints. ...
(Date:10/19/2014)... 19, 2014 NextCODE Health, which enables clinicians and ... real time, today announced the launch of its new genomic ... at the American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG) annual meeting ... sign up and apply for free beta access, visit ... benefits can be viewed here . The ...
(Date:10/19/2014)... (PRWEB) October 19, 2014 The Asia-Pacific ... Analytics market in Asia-Pacific with analysis and forecast of ... million in 2014 to $208 million by 2019, at ... 2014 to 2019. , Browse through the TOC of ... idea of the in-depth analysis provided. It also provides ...
Breaking Biology Technology:PureTech Announces Expansion with Oversubscribed $55M Funding Round 2PureTech Announces Expansion with Oversubscribed $55M Funding Round 3PureTech Announces Expansion with Oversubscribed $55M Funding Round 4PureTech Announces Expansion with Oversubscribed $55M Funding Round 5PureTech Announces Expansion with Oversubscribed $55M Funding Round 6Cascade Veterinary Referral Center Seeks Candidates for an Investigational Study of Stem Cells for Dogs with Arthritis 2The NextCODE Exchange: The first global, real-time system for sharing full-resolution genomic data 2The NextCODE Exchange: The first global, real-time system for sharing full-resolution genomic data 3The Asia-Pacific Speech Analytics market is estimated to reach $208 million by 2019 - New Report by MicroMarket Monitor 2The Asia-Pacific Speech Analytics market is estimated to reach $208 million by 2019 - New Report by MicroMarket Monitor 3The Asia-Pacific Speech Analytics market is estimated to reach $208 million by 2019 - New Report by MicroMarket Monitor 4
... Calif., March 1, 2011 MAP Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Nasdaq: ... year ended December 31, 2010. The net loss for ... to $13.4 million during the same period in 2009. The net ... compared to $9.0 million for the year ended December 31, 2009. ...
... NBS ), an international biopharmaceutical company with operations ... Smith, the Company,s Chairman and CEO, will present on Tuesday, ... Annual Analyst Conference. The Conference will be held at the ... York. Dr. Smith will present as part of Track 2: ...
... 2011 /PRNewswire-Asia-FirstCall/ -- ShengdaTech, Inc. ("ShengdaTech" or the "Company") ... nano-precipitated calcium carbonate ("NPCC") in China, today announced that ... Anhui Guo, COO and acting CFO and Mr. A. ... & Renshaw Annual China Investment Conference to be held ...
Cached Biology Technology:MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 2MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 3MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 4MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 5MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 6MAP Pharmaceuticals Reports 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results 7NeoStem to Present at Wall Street Forum 2011 Financial Conference on Tuesday, March 1 2NeoStem to Present at Wall Street Forum 2011 Financial Conference on Tuesday, March 1 3NeoStem to Present at Wall Street Forum 2011 Financial Conference on Tuesday, March 1 4ShengdaTech to Present at Rodman & Renshaw Annual China Investment Conference in Shanghai 2
... RNAi Kit is optimized for ... amounts of ready-to-use dsRNA for ... The MEGAscript RNAi Kit is ... transcription technol-ogy and includes reagents ...
Total Proteins from over 50 different human Alzheimer, Diabetic, Liver Cirrhosis, and Lupus diseased tissues are available....
... building blocks, Parker can create economical ... that are ideal for pick-and-place and ... Parker can also integrate pneumatic axes, ... ,guarding., Standard or custom configurations ...
... its patented technology, the Lone Wolf valve ... Normally Open proportional valve available on the ... provides repeatable high-speed performance, and ensures maximum ... , Enhances system control and patient comfort. ...
Biology Products: