Navigation Links
Has modern science become dysfunctional?
Date:3/27/2012

The recent explosion in the number of retractions in scientific journals is just the tip of the iceberg and a symptom of a greater dysfunction that has been evolving the world of biomedical research say the editors-in-chief of two prominent journals in a presentation before a committee of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) today.

"Incentives have evolved over the decades to encourage some behaviors that are detrimental to good science," says Ferric Fang, editor-in-chief of the journal Infection and Immunity, a publication of the American Society for Microbiology (ASM), who is speaking today at the meeting of the Committee of Science, Technology, and Law of the NAS along with Arturo Casadevall, editor-in -chief of mBio, the ASM's online, open-access journal.

In the past decade the number of retraction notices for scientific journals has increased more than 10-fold while the number of journals articles published has only increased by 44%. While retractions still represent a very small percentage of the total, the increase is still disturbing because it undermines society's confidence in scientific results and on public policy decisions that are based on those results, says Casadevall. Some of the retractions are due to simple error but many are a result of misconduct including falsification of data and plagiarism.

More concerning, say the editors, is that this trend may be a symptom of a growing dysfunction in the biomedical sciences, one that needs to be addressed soon. At the heart of the problem is an economic incentive system fueling a hypercompetitive environment that is fostering poor scientific practices, including frank misconduct.

The root of the problem is a lack of sufficient resources to sustain the current enterprise. Too many researchers are competing for too little funding, creating a survival-of-the-fittest, winner-take-all environment where researchers increasingly feel pressure to publ
'/>"/>

Contact: Jim Sliwa
jsliwa@asmusa.org
202-942-9297
American Society for Microbiology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Ancient whale species sheds new light on its modern relatives
2. Modern Mobility Aids, Inc. Announces a Revised Agreement for the Acquisition of Lumigene
3. European Neandertals were on the verge of extinction even before the arrival of modern humans
4. Modern genetics answers age-old question on Garrods fourth inborn error of metabolism
5. Invasion of genomic parasites triggered modern mammalian pregnancy
6. Evolutions past is modern humans present
7. Researchers discover oldest evidence of nails in modern primates
8. Modern fish communities live fast and die young
9. Modern EU agriculture jeopardizes biodiversity in new member states
10. Mummies tell history of a modern plague
11. Low-cost molecular medicine should be included in modern eye physicians tool kit
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/17/2014)... PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] After decades of decline, ... Cod,s saltmarshes. To the eye, the marsh in those ... clear that a key service of the marsh ... aesthetics back but the ecosystem function hasn,t come back," ... and senior author of the study in the journal ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... KNOXVILLEScience has learned a great deal about complex social ... might have something to teach too. , With their ... advanced cognition, parrots live in a complex social environment---not ... as bees or ants, but in a dynamic setting ... the most intelligent mammals: dolphins, whales, primates, and social ...
(Date:9/16/2014)... women in Australia is increased by lower socioeconomic ... September) in BJOG: An International Journal of ... high standards of living; however, existing research has ... indigenous and non indigenous Australians. , This case-control ... socioeconomic position on severe maternal morbidities associated with ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 2Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 3Being social: Learning from the behavior of birds 2New study examines the impact of socioeconomic position & maternal morbidity in Australia 2New study examines the impact of socioeconomic position & maternal morbidity in Australia 3
... sediments laid down shortly after an asteroid plowed into the ... is linked to widespread global extinctions including the demise of ... first fauna to show themselves following the global catastrophe. ... is often on the survival and proliferation of mammals, paleo-botanical ...
... The Dow Chemical Company has awarded UC Santa ... research initiative that will help shape the future of ... Materials Institute at UCSB will educate future scientists and ... with applications that range from novel polymers to next-generation ...
... Assigning environment-related legal cases to specialized tribunals, courts ... experts convene in Malaysia for a two-day United Nations ... and governance systems and sustainable development. High court ... country,s Supreme Court to ensure judges have the expertise ...
Cached Biology News:Worms among first animals to surface after K-T extinction event, CU-led study finds 2Worms among first animals to surface after K-T extinction event, CU-led study finds 3UCSB awarded $15 million by Dow to establish collaborative institute for materials research and education 2UCSB awarded $15 million by Dow to establish collaborative institute for materials research and education 3Specialized courts for environment cases among proposals as law experts mull green governance 2Specialized courts for environment cases among proposals as law experts mull green governance 3Specialized courts for environment cases among proposals as law experts mull green governance 4Specialized courts for environment cases among proposals as law experts mull green governance 5
(Date:9/17/2014)... -- BioClinica®, Inc., a leading provider of outsourced clinical ... its experts are speaking at the 20th Annual ... held September 28 to October 1 in ... the innovative Compass technology, a risk-based monitoring ... earlier this year, is up for the Technology ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... PITTSBURGH , Sept. 17, 2014 ... maker of MD-Cu 29 antimicrobial copper, announces Gilmour ... points to the first EPA-registered antimicrobial solid touch surface ... copper is a reasonably priced surface that kills greater ... 2 hours of exposure. 1 ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... MARLBOROUGH, Mass. , Sept. 17, 2014 /PRNewswire/ ... ), a biotechnology company focused on discovering, developing ... needs using RNA-targeted technologies, today announced that it has ... Patent and Trademark Office on its unique delivery ... ® ) to phagocytic cells for the treatment ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... 2014 First antibacterial ... a truly novel class of anti-infective in ... a biopharmaceutical company developing a truly novel ... has secured £4.0m ($6.4m) to advance the ... a range of Gram-positive infections including  Clostridium ...
Breaking Biology Technology:BioClinica to Present at 20th Annual SCDM Conference 2BioClinica to Present at 20th Annual SCDM Conference 3Innovative Gilmour Academy Ice Arena changes more than 200 fixtures to Hussey Copper's MD-Cu29 antimicrobial copper to help protect against bacteria 2Innovative Gilmour Academy Ice Arena changes more than 200 fixtures to Hussey Copper's MD-Cu29 antimicrobial copper to help protect against bacteria 3RXi Pharmaceuticals Strengthens Intellectual Property Portfolio 2RXi Pharmaceuticals Strengthens Intellectual Property Portfolio 3RXi Pharmaceuticals Strengthens Intellectual Property Portfolio 4MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 2MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 3MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 4MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 5MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 6MGB Biopharma Secures £4.0m ($6.4m) to Advance its Novel Lead Antibacterial, MGB-BP-3, into Clinical Development 7
... Nektar Therapeutics,(Nasdaq: NKTR ) will announce ... December 31, 2008 on Wednesday, February 25, 2009, after ... and chief executive,officer, will host a conference call to ... p.m. Pacific Time (PT). , ...
... Feb. 11 XTL,Biopharmaceuticals Ltd. (Nasdaq: XTLB ... Mr. Boaz Shweiger have been appointed to XTL,s Board ... also be assuming,the role of Co-Chief Executive Officer, with ... alternatives. , Ron Bentsur, Co-Chief ...
... ARLINGTON, Va., Feb. 11 Scientists engaged in biological ... in their 2009 lab budgets. BioInformatics, LLC ( ... the life science market, has released preliminary data from ... Down Market: Strategies for Life Science Suppliers. In ...
Cached Biology Technology:Nektar to Announce Year-End 2008 Financial Results on Wednesday, February 25, 2009 After Close of U.S.-Based Financial Markets 2XTL Biopharmaceuticals Announces Appointment of David Grossman and Boaz Shweiger to Board of Directors 2XTL Biopharmaceuticals Announces Appointment of David Grossman and Boaz Shweiger to Board of Directors 3Life Science Labs Reacting to the Economic Crisis 2
... is a member of a nuclear ... that heterodimerize with retinoic acid-like receptor ... regulation of glucose and lipid metabolism. ... anti-diabetic agents called thiazolidinediones (TZD) or ...
... Preparation Reconstitution: one vial contains ... ficoll and 50 mg PVP; ... water yields a 50concentrate Special ... 1.00 g/mL (20 C) Quality ...
... Antibody Capture Kit eliminates ... optimization steps typically required ... This kit enables the ... multiple antigens based on ...
... This CLS number is a new ... Cornings product number. If showing no ... old Sigma-Aldrich number (R4276) or contact ... cap polystyrene (expanded surface, easy grip) ...
Biology Products: