Navigation Links
Has modern science become dysfunctional?
Date:3/27/2012

The recent explosion in the number of retractions in scientific journals is just the tip of the iceberg and a symptom of a greater dysfunction that has been evolving the world of biomedical research say the editors-in-chief of two prominent journals in a presentation before a committee of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) today.

"Incentives have evolved over the decades to encourage some behaviors that are detrimental to good science," says Ferric Fang, editor-in-chief of the journal Infection and Immunity, a publication of the American Society for Microbiology (ASM), who is speaking today at the meeting of the Committee of Science, Technology, and Law of the NAS along with Arturo Casadevall, editor-in -chief of mBio, the ASM's online, open-access journal.

In the past decade the number of retraction notices for scientific journals has increased more than 10-fold while the number of journals articles published has only increased by 44%. While retractions still represent a very small percentage of the total, the increase is still disturbing because it undermines society's confidence in scientific results and on public policy decisions that are based on those results, says Casadevall. Some of the retractions are due to simple error but many are a result of misconduct including falsification of data and plagiarism.

More concerning, say the editors, is that this trend may be a symptom of a growing dysfunction in the biomedical sciences, one that needs to be addressed soon. At the heart of the problem is an economic incentive system fueling a hypercompetitive environment that is fostering poor scientific practices, including frank misconduct.

The root of the problem is a lack of sufficient resources to sustain the current enterprise. Too many researchers are competing for too little funding, creating a survival-of-the-fittest, winner-take-all environment where researchers increasingly feel pressure to publ
'/>"/>

Contact: Jim Sliwa
jsliwa@asmusa.org
202-942-9297
American Society for Microbiology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Ancient whale species sheds new light on its modern relatives
2. Modern Mobility Aids, Inc. Announces a Revised Agreement for the Acquisition of Lumigene
3. European Neandertals were on the verge of extinction even before the arrival of modern humans
4. Modern genetics answers age-old question on Garrods fourth inborn error of metabolism
5. Invasion of genomic parasites triggered modern mammalian pregnancy
6. Evolutions past is modern humans present
7. Researchers discover oldest evidence of nails in modern primates
8. Modern fish communities live fast and die young
9. Modern EU agriculture jeopardizes biodiversity in new member states
10. Mummies tell history of a modern plague
11. Low-cost molecular medicine should be included in modern eye physicians tool kit
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/28/2014)... became the first man to reach the South Pole ... an international team of scientists led by Joe McConnell ... air pollution from industrial activities arrived long before. , ... spaced locations around the Antarctic continent, including the South ... reconstruction to date of lead pollution over the Earth,s ...
(Date:7/27/2014)... largest prevalence studies to date, researchers from the U.K. ... the hepatitis C virus (HCV). Findings published in Hepatology, ... of Liver Diseases, indicate that genotype 1 is the ... of which one-third reside in East Asia. Genotype 3, ... most prevalent, followed by genotypes 2, 4, 6, and ...
(Date:7/27/2014)... shown the potential for global climate change to cut ... part, ignored the interactions between increasing temperature and air ... damage crops. , A new study involving researchers at ... suggesting that policymakers need to take both warming and ... The study looked in detail at global production of ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Industrial lead pollution beat explorers to the South Pole by 22 years and persists today 2Industrial lead pollution beat explorers to the South Pole by 22 years and persists today 3Hepatitis C virus genotype 1 is most prevalent worldwide 2Study: Climate change and air pollution will combine to curb food supplies 2Study: Climate change and air pollution will combine to curb food supplies 3
... among the authors of a new paper that describes ... when and how to use an environmental strategy known ... assistant professors of biology, and Alejandro Camacho, associate professor ... that produced the paper, which appears in this week,s ...
... are several risk factors for the development of Alzheimer,s ... of studies linking these risk factors with Vitamin D ... Journal of Alzheimer,s Disease (May 2009) by ... Health Research Center (SUNARC) suggests that further investigation of ...
... wounded during combat, surgeons must focus on reducing infection ... improve the repair and regeneration processes are being developed ... not being moved quickly enough into military trauma centers. ... for Advanced Bioengineering for Soldier Survivability want to change ...
Cached Biology News:Notre Dame researchers describe new tool for evaluating 'managed relocations' 2Notre Dame researchers describe new tool for evaluating 'managed relocations' 3Is vitamin D deficiency linked to Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia? 2New center at Georgia Tech aims to improve recovery of soldiers with severe injuries 2New center at Georgia Tech aims to improve recovery of soldiers with severe injuries 3
(Date:7/28/2014)... 2014   Propeller Health , the FDA-cleared digital ... of Brad Towle as Senior Vice President, ... driving the company,s sales growth, customer acquisition and program ... specifically his past role in the development of accountable ... this pivotal time in the industry," said David ...
(Date:7/28/2014)... , July 28, 2014  InterMune, Inc. (NASDAQ: ... release its second quarter 2014 financial results at the ... 2014. A live conference call and webcast will be hosted ... day. Interested investors and others may participate ... +1 212-231-2900 (international), conference ID#21728775. A replay of the webcast ...
(Date:7/26/2014)... Albany, NY (PRWEB) July 26, 2014 ... 2020 provides key market data on the Canada ... in millions of US dollars, volume (in units) ... segments - High-End Endoscopy Visualization Systems, Mid-Range Endoscopy ... Browse Full Report at http://www.marketresearchreports.biz/analysis/213254 . , ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... University of Leicester has furthered our understanding of ... create new materials using nanosized ,building blocks,. , ... prestigious academic journal Physical Review Letters , ... rich detail the structure and internal atomic motion ... and a single helium atom. , The technique ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Propeller Health Hires Brad Towle as Senior Vice President of Business and Client Development 2InterMune to Release Second Quarter Financial Results on August 6 2Canada Endoscopy Visualization Systems Market Outlook to 2020: MarketResearchReports.Biz 2Canada Endoscopy Visualization Systems Market Outlook to 2020: MarketResearchReports.Biz 3Canada Endoscopy Visualization Systems Market Outlook to 2020: MarketResearchReports.Biz 4Canada Endoscopy Visualization Systems Market Outlook to 2020: MarketResearchReports.Biz 5Breakthrough laser experiment reveals liquid-like motion of atoms in an ultra-cold cluster 2Breakthrough laser experiment reveals liquid-like motion of atoms in an ultra-cold cluster 3
... tumor,s vulnerability yields durable responses in Phase I/II ... ... 21 Systems Medicine, LLC (SM),a wholly-owned subsidiary of Cell Therapeutics, ... phase I trial,combining cisplatin with brostallicin in patients with solid tumors ...
... Nov. 21 Syngenta and the Royal,Society of Chemistry ... to help promote the economic and social development of,the ... continent,is being established initially in Kenya. Its purpose is ... to achieve greater levels of,innovation and scientific development., ...
... paper to be published Nov. 22 in the online ... of Wisconsin-Madison researchers reports the genetic reprogramming of human ... cells., The finding is not only a critical scientific ... landscape of stem cell biology as human embryos may ...
Cached Biology Technology:Brostallicin Trial Data Demonstrates Encouraging Anti-tumor Activity in Patients With Chemotherapy-Resistant Cancers 2Brostallicin Trial Data Demonstrates Encouraging Anti-tumor Activity in Patients With Chemotherapy-Resistant Cancers 3Syngenta and The Royal Society of Chemistry Launch African Science Initiative 2Syngenta and The Royal Society of Chemistry Launch African Science Initiative 3UW-Madison scientists guide human skin cells to embryonic state 2UW-Madison scientists guide human skin cells to embryonic state 3
... 9001:2000 Certified USDA Research Registered OLAW Assured ... Training AALAS Certified Technicians Documentation ... Documentation Upon Request Focus CRP ... all your custom immunology service needs. ...
Request Info...
... include: ,ICC and IHC Protocol Development ... ,Antibody Screenings in Animal or Human ... of Cells and Tissues ,Peroxidase, Alkaline ... Fluorescent, or Electron Microscopy ,Protein Localization ...
Request Info...
Biology Products: